Showing posts with label MDEQ. Show all posts
Showing posts with label MDEQ. Show all posts

Tuesday, May 12, 2015

MDEQ Issues Permit Change to Further Limit CAFO Winter Manure Spreading

Paul F. Bohn, Esq.

The Michigan Department of Environmental Quality (MDEQ) announced a change to its permits for large farms as part of the state’s efforts to better protect Michigan waters from agricultural runoff. Confined Animal Feeding Operations (CAFO) were already limited in when and where they could spread manure, but the permit change applies those limits to operations receiving that manure as well.

We have written previously on Ohio’s efforts to combat the “harmful algae blooms” plaguing Lake Erie, and this effort by MDEQ is certainly part of Michigan’s response to protect Lake Erie.

CAFOs are not allowed to spread manure on frozen or snow-covered grounds except under very strict, limited circumstances, but they were previously allowed to transfer their excess manure to other operations not specifically prohibited from “winter spreading.”

Now, large farms are not permitted to transfer their farm waste to other operations from January through March unless the recipient follows the winter spreading standards. Witnesses at the hearings on the CAFO permit renewal said that the transferred manure, which was spread onto the recipients’ lands, was running into streams and drains as the snow was melting during the spring thaw. 

“The change is expected to further minimize incidents of farm runoff to surface waters during spring melts, and will safeguard Michigan's valuable water resources while providing a reasonable regulatory framework for farmers," said MDEQ in a press release.

This permit change has been in the works since December of last year, and a public hearing was held in January. The final product includes revisions based on public comment. Both the permit and the summary on public comments can be viewed on MDEQ’s website here:



Paul Bohn, partner at Fausone Bohn, LLP, has established a strong reputation in Michigan as a leading practitioner in environmental law. Mr. Bohn has been selected as a Michigan Super Lawyer since 2010 and was named one of the Top Attorneys in Michigan in 2014 by Crain’s Detroit Business. The team at Fausone Bohn, LLP has extensive experience dealing with MDEQ matters. If you need consultation, don’t hesitate to contact us at (248) 468-4536 or online at www.fb-firm.com. 

Tuesday, January 6, 2015

Fracking Debate Percolates in Michigan on Heel of New York Ban

Paul Bohn, Esq.

On the heels of the State of New York’s banning of hydraulic fracturing, debate on the practice is now percolating in Michigan. New York, which has had a moratorium on the practice since 2008, now joins Vermont as the only states to completely ban hydraulic fracturing, commonly known as “fracking.”

The Michigan Department of Environmental Quality (MDEQ) is set to draft rules in April to regulate the industry. These new rules will reportedly include provisions to limit a local government’s ability to pass zoning ordinances to prevent fracking.

In 2014, MDEQ also introduced a new draft of proposed Hydraulic Fracturing Rules. Interested readers can find that draft at: http://www7.dleg.state.mi.us/orr/Files/ORR/1298_2013-101EQ_orr-draft.pdf

The move by New York to ban fracking is sure to embolden anti-fracking activists, while at the same time signal the pro-fracking lobby to dig in their heels in other states – including Michigan. New York Governor Andrew Cuomo said the issue was “probably the most emotionally charged issue I have experienced…”

The oil and gas industry in New York had their hopes shot down by the decision, as New York sits atop one of the largest natural gas deposits in the United States. Some energy companies have leased land in those areas and have been waiting for years to tap into those thousands of acres of land. And the wait will go on.

Michigan, too, has a sizeable natural gas supply. In-state natural gas represents about 20% of the total gas consumed in Michigan. And MDEQ notes in a one page briefing document on their website that fracking has been in regular use in Michigan since 1952, with no adverse effects to the state’s environment from the process. You can check out MDEQ’s “Five facts about Hydraulic Fracturing” here:

However, a group in Michigan, known as The Committee to Ban Fracking in Michigan, begs to differ. They hailed the decision out of New York. Also, with the abysmal turnout in this past election, the bar for getting a ballot proposal put on the 2016 ticket is far lower. For 2016, only 252,522 signatures are required to send a question to the Michigan voters, and the anti-fracking group is eyeing to do just that.

The group alleges that the industry has indeed been harmful to the Michigan environment, including wasting fresh water resources, putting aquifers in danger, and the introduction of harmful fracking wastes and radioactive materials. The group’s campaign, LetsBanFracking.org, hopes that the New York decision emboldens potential donors and volunteers.

So stay tuned for 2015 – fracking has been on the top of many an insider’s list of hot-button issues to watch. And if New York is any indication, it seems that will come to fruition.


Paul Bohn, partner at Fausone Bohn, LLP, has established a strong reputation in Michigan as a leading practitioner in the areas of environmental law, real estate, municipal regulations and construction law. 

Thursday, July 15, 2010

Solid Waste Disposal Decreasing in Michigan

The MDEQ recently announced that for fiscal year 2009 Michigan residents and businesses decreased their total solid waste volume by 13%. Waste imported from other states and Canada also reportedly decreased by roughly 24%. Good news to the extent that this significant reduction is attributable to an increased focus on sustainability. Every silver lining has a host rain cloud though, and the MDEQ was quick to point out that the $0.21 per ton fee on solid waste disposed in Michigan landfills is what funds its solid waste program and the continued decline in solid waste disposal means there are fewer dollars to fund that program. The MDEQ stated that this has “serious implications for Michigan’s ability to continue the current level of permitting, inspections and oversight of solid waste management in the state.” The press release went on to say that Michigan’s disposal fee is the lowest in the Great Lakes region. Translation: you can expect that the MDEQ will be asking for a fee increase.

This past year our client, the City of Westland, joined the effort to reduce solid waste disposal volumes. During the summer of 2009 the City implemented a curbside recycling program for all residential units, and as a result has seen its landfill waste drop by about 25% in the last quarter of 2009. The City is starting to see both cost savings and new revenues, and Mayor William Wild is thrilled with the outcome of the program to date. Our firm had the privilege of negotiating the contracts with each of the recycling program vendors.

If you have environmental questions, feel free to contact Andrea Montbriand at andrea@fb-firm.com.